We all had our hearts broken last night, when the Dallas Cowboys lost. And not only did they lose, but they lost to the New York Giants, the only team in the NFL everybody hates. (You may notice I am not a man that refers to the Dallas Cowboys as “us” or “we,” I do not play, I’m not on the team. I have no say in the decisions they make. They don’t know my name, don’t care about me or my family. In fact, they appear to hate me.)
This comes after an offseason and pre-season of promise. The defense would be better, they would be solid, together, the team chemistry would be terrific, and of course, a Super Bowl run was probable, maybe inevitable. And against all reason, I started to believe. This would be the year, again, finally. The pieces would coalesce into the most beautiful masterpiece. (We all stopped using the word “could” and used “would” instead. This is it, baby, they’re ready, let’s goooooooo!)
Did you know in the last 9 years, the Dallas Cowboys were 16-2 against the Giants? They were totally average, but at least they always beat the Giants. There was always that. They had an offseason to come out hot and justify all of the promise and hope, and didn’t. Did you also know the last 3 seasons, the Giants were 6-11, 3-14, and 4-13? 13-38 overall? Did you know that?
And I’m stuck thinking about why, why do I continue to do this? Why do I keep thinking this year is different? What kind of nonsense tricks any of us into believing sports fandom is any different from any other kind of consumerism?
Let’s say you have a favorite restaurant, where you’ve had years of fantastic meals, and made so many great memories. It’s your favorite by a million miles, you’d wear a t-shirt and talk in a tv advertisement, you’d tell all of your friends and write about it on your personal blog, and you’d do this all for free. As a matter of fact, it has even become a part of who you are, your personality, this restaurant just fits you like a pair of old jeans. Ok?
Now, let’s say that restaurant starts to serve absolutely garbage. They fire the chef and the best servers, bringing in new ones that they promise better suit the vision. They’d disrespectfully refuse to pay market value for the best one, sending him to the Green Bay Packers. The portions keep getting smaller and smaller while the prices sky-rocket. They assume they have your business no matter what happens, so they stopped caring about you or any other customers. It is no longer a quality product, it has become no more than an altar to the owner’s ego.
You might go for a while, maybe quite a long while, remembering how it was and crossing your fingers that it could be that way again. But eventually…eventually, you’d find a new restaurant, wouldn’t you?
You’d change dish detergents if Dawn stopped getting your dishes clean. Even if you have had Fords your whole life, you’d consider a Toyota after enough lemons. We are a disposable society, we get rid of our spouses if they stop making us feel good for a weekend! But not our football teams?!!??? Why not?? This is absolute nonsense.
One of the best people I know is a Cleveland Browns fan. Why would anyone ever do that to themselves?? But, then again, why do I? Why do I hang around, hoping that the Dallas Cowboys will turn it all around and start serving great food again? There is no evidence that this could happen, but even if it did, who’s to say I couldn’t just go back?
We’re mostly all bandwagon consumers, aren’t we? So, why is that such a terrible thing only in sports?
The more I think about it, I’m never leaving The Angel. Ever. The baseball team I like is the Detroit Tigers because Alan Trammell and Sweet Lou Whitaker were the SS/2B combo in the late ‘70’s/early ‘80’s. Morrissey is my favorite in music, and I wait and listen to his singles and albums the day they come out…his latest, Make-Up Is A Lie, is so bad it’s aggressively offensive, and I just heard there is a new album coming our early next year and I am so excited to listen. Even though he is on a clear down slide, maybe it’ll be his best yet. I use a phone that is pretty hopelessly out of date; sometimes we stream our Sunday services and, inexplicably, there is no sound. I’m not getting a new one, this is my phone. There are holes in all of my socks. I don’t know that I would change dish detergents or find a new restaurant. I haven’t bought new jeans in years. I don’t know that I am a bandwagon consumer…
I wouldn’t call it loyalty or anything positive, I’d probably call it a disorder. I’ll likely keep getting bitten by this same Dallas Cowboys dog every year for the rest of my life. (Really, losing to the Giants?!!!????) When I’m 65 or 85 or 105, I’ll be saying, “I think this is their year.” And I might still have this phone, too, but that doesn’t make it right. That Cleveland Browns guy should totally move on, if he knows what’s good for him.
